On Friday, March 15th there was a tragic shooting at the Muslim mosque prayer service here in Christchurch. It was a hate crime in the name of white supremacy. 50 people were killed, half a dozen are still in critical condition, and many will need medical, and emotional, care the rest of their lives. We are grieving, along with everyone over here, the loss of precious, innocent lives.
Many friends and family have asked how we are doing, and I think it would be good to try to figure that out through writing. I have been feeling awful about how front and center my own emotions and thoughts have been the past 10 days, and ashamed to face or share them. I think it might help to be honest.
At my women’s bible study Thursday we were given some notes from a local counselor that started with this:
“When we come through a trauma we may experience shock or even just fuzzy brain; finding it hard to concentrate as usual.”
That simple sentence was so freeing, because I have spent way too much energy feeling awful that I didn’t feel more, and often don’t feel anything when I hear tragic news. I usually find it hard to concentrate and pray like I want to. In hindsight it makes sense that this might be a normal response, but hearing it from a professional really helped me to not feel so heartless. Also, I have been thinking, and telling the kids, that what you’re feeling or not feeling isn’t as important as what you do in response.
I heard of the shooting through a text from Chris at 3 pm, letting me know that the boys were in lockdown at their school and he would let me know when he heard anything more. A couple hours later nothing had changed…and finally three hours later, at 6 pm, I heard that he was able to get them and bring them home. I knew there was a major shooting in the city center, and I chose not to look it up on the news, because I wanted to be present with Twill and not upset myself.
So Twill and I baked muffins and listened to the Okee Dokee Brothers music on my phone, because I wasn’t much up for talking to an argumentative preschooler. He loves helping me in the kitchen these days, I dare say it’s his passion. So we just puttered around in the kitchen for most of the time, slowly making supper, then eating ours and going on with the night.
When Chris and the boys finally walked in the door around 6:30 I was so glad to see them. My heart aches now with relief, but at the moment I was trying to carry on like normal. I fed them warm grilled cheese, squash and apple bake, and cold blueberry muffins. Wesley says now that grilled cheese and blueberry muffins are his favorite foods, and I think it likely has something to do with the circumstances and hunger of that night.
Ilam school took very good care of the boys, and we were thankful that they didn’t inform them of what was going on. I think, like me, many of the teachers didn’t know much of what was going on at the time. They knew they had children to take care of in the moment, and they did what they could to make it a pleasant experience. I heard some really sad stories of private schools in the area who had kids sitting silently under desks in the dark. I am thankful that Ilam school did nothing to scare our boys and left discussing the details up to us as parents. Chris did hear some rumors that kids were speculating when he picked them up, but rumors can be exposed as just rumors.
When I tucked the boys into bed that night they seemed to have had a good day, and I felt relieved. But the guilt was slowly mounting that I still hadn’t given enough thought to the victims. I got the details from Chris after the boys went to bed. It was neat to hear that though this guy video recorded the shooting himself for all the world to see (17 minutes of him shooting people), they were not broadcasting it, because they knew that it was what he wanted.
I was really surprised that both my mom and Chris’ mom heard the news about it and messaged us just a few minutes after I heard from Chris, at the beginning of the lockdown. I was also surprised how many friends here in Christchurch texted me, during the lockdown, to see how we were doing. Some were very apologetic already that we had to experience this here in New Zealand.
Saturday morning the whole city seemed to be shut down. There was no Parkrun, all the toy libraries were closed, and there were hardly any cars on the streets. Of course it’s impossible to sort out how much of it was fear and how much was grief. I know it was both. We were happy to all stay together for the day, for sure. Late in the morning all six of us walked to the grocery store together, because we were hosting some American friends for dinner that night. People at the grocery store were notably friendlier.
It’s neat how that has in general been a city-wide response to this shooting. Everywhere I go people are acknowledging each other more than before. Making eye contact, smiling, saying ‘hi.’ Random strangers, especially at school, will ask each other, ‘How are you doing?” and really care.
And we are all especially aware of Muslim women in headdress, knowing so many of them have been widowed and traumatized. There are many Muslim families at Ilam School that are directly affected. The distinction in dress has been a gift, because we can recognize and reach out. I know little of the Muslim culture, and have been trying to learn more through stories and movies this past week. I know there is a huge spectrum within, but one thing I’ve learned is that in extreme sects the women are supposed to cover themselves so as not to be seen. But in this case it is helping them to be seen, and loved, by many.
The Sunday after the shooting we all went to morning church (we usually go to the evening service on campus). Chris was a little uneasy about being in a large, religious congregation in the wake of such an event, and I wondered if anyone else would feel that way. But the crowd was even thicker than our previous time there.
The whole service addressed the events of the weekend. Many people got up and prayed for everyone involved in the situation, people I hadn’t even thought of in my fuzzy brain. I was so incredibly thankful for the reality that we are stronger together than apart. The Body of Christ is a beautiful thing with everyone bringing their unique prayers that I hadn’t put words to. I was so thankful for those prayers.
The message was about the ways that we can love our Muslim neighbors, looking at the good Samaritan passage. There really is no “us and them” divisive mentality of fear in the church here, even though we don’t agree religiously. These are people, loved by God, in need right now. I didn’t have any expectations going in at all, but the way this community is addressing it makes me more aware of the divisiveness, and defensiveness, I have experienced back home.
The way the prime minister here has responded to the tragedy is a stark contrast as well to our president’s defensiveness. I have to admit, I have fallen in love with the whole country over this horrible, horrible reality, because of the love in the wake. There is clearly so much shame felt by people here that this could happen in New Zealand, when they work so hard to be inclusive. And most are giving all they’ve got to show it now.
Chris took us all down to the wall of flowers in the city center after dinner last Thursday. It’s over a city block of flowers several feet deep that individuals have given with notes of love. Many signs said “We are One” or “They are Us” or “You should have been safe.” You can see much of this in the media, but it was quite different to go in person and see so many people there at the same time, so affected. It all makes me incredibly aware of my own personal reactions.

One overwhelming feeling I have been wrestling with is awe and inferiority at the responses of people here. Everyone I meet seems so respectable, people I could stand to learn so much from. And seeing how respectable their leader is, and how much they respect her, it just feels like such a healthy culture that I sadly can’t relate to. Everyone was so ashamed that this could happen here and apologetic and I kept thinking who on earth wouldn’t want to move here if this is how this kind of thing is handled.
It didn’t help that Chris’ students were falling in love with him at the same time and many have been encouraging him to stay and apply here. I entertained the fantasy, though I knew it was a bad idea, for a few days, thinking maybe I would become a better person if I moved here. But I can see that for what it is, putting my hope in external things to change me, instead of my Jesus and hard work.
The other feeling I have been ashamed to admit is how desensitized I actually am to hate crimes, and the threat of crazy people with guns. It is so sad that it doesn’t surprise me anymore. And I feel so insensitive when everyone here is in so much shock. It reveals their innocence and my lack of it.
We had a helpful conversation at my women’s bible study last week that gave me some perspective on this. We were processing and addressing the shooting for bible study, instead of continuing in Matthew. We looked at some Psalms and talked about fear, to begin with. I’ve been hearing from many people here that their sense of safety and security has been taken from them. But honestly, I don’t know what it feels like to feel safe in the way that they used to.
I’ve never actually been held at gunpoint, so I feel like I have little room to talk. But the reality is there’s a spectrum here of safety and I’m in a very different part of it growing up in the USA. Even in my small rural Midwestern town there was murder, and drugs, and so many hunting accidents. There were school shootings in the news when I was in school. When I was in high school if anyone asked me what I was afraid of I would answer, without hesitation, “scary people!” Basically what I meant by that was crazed people with guns that might hurt me.
But what I realized in our bible study discussion was that God has really done a great work in me to free me from those fears. Fear for my own life is not something I’ve been facing in the wake of this. I’ve faced it for decades, and ultimately, I am not afraid of death. Jesus says, “Do not be afraid of those who kill the body, but cannot kill the soul. Rather, be afraid of the One who can destroy both soul and body in hell.” (Matthew 10:28) I have other fears that I need Jesus to help me conquer still, but I am learning that the only antidote to my fears is fear of God.
So that discussion shook me out of my fantasy about moving to New Zealand, because I realized how hypocritical it would be to move here to protect my children from danger in America, and put my hope in what seems to be a healthier situation, when God has done such a freeing work in me in the midst of danger back home. My safety is only ever in Jesus, no matter what transpires around me.
Truth be told, though, today I took great comfort in simple daily routines. The fact that I make eggs and oatmeal for breakfast every school day morning felt like such a huge comfort. This afternoon Twill and I were dancing to the Okee Dokee Brothers music and I realized that I do miss my homeland. Music has such a way of bypassing my head straight into my heart. I miss a good live banjo! I miss bluegrass music, and gospel music! But it’s not just the music, it’s the people who make it. The heart and hardship behind it. I love my wild, if sometimes frantic, nation.
So that’s where I’m at with all this, at the moment. I’m not proud of it and don’t plan to stay here. I feel very childish and self-centered. But I can see that I need to love myself and have compassion on myself to move forward. That’s why I write.
I am just one weak person trying to make sense of insanity. I know I can’t fix it, but pray I can do something to ease other’s pain. We have found a few opportunities to give, and chances to acknowledge others pain in passing at school. But it’s hard not to feel a bit on the outside of the whole community, because we’re here for such a short time. I am thankful for any prayers for the whole situation.